Feature: Audit Exposes: How an Accountability Crisis Led to a Ksh. 9.6 Billion Loss on eCitizen

Kenya’s flagship digital payment system, eCitizen, is at the center of a financial storm following an audit report that reveals Ksh.9.6 billion in questionable transactions, systemic mismanagement, and potential fraud. Auditor General Nancy Gathungu’s latest findings paint a grim picture of a platform meant to streamline government services but now riddled with accountability gaps that threaten public service delivery.

[ays_block_subscribe id=’1′]

At the center of the crisis is the absence of binding contracts between the National Treasury and financial service providers handling eCitizen transactions. Without signed Service Level Agreements (SLAs), a staggering Ksh.7.05 billion remains in limbo, stuck in collection accounts with no clear oversight. Gathungu warns that this lack of regulation allows firms to potentially misuse public funds, delaying remittances to ministries, departments, and counties, ultimately crippling essential services.

The audit further uncovered Ksh.2.57 billion in receipts that could not be traced to any invoices, raising serious concerns about fraud, duplicate payments, and revenue leakage. In one instance, while the Government Digital Payments Unit reported Ksh.2.24 billion owed to the Tourism Fund, actual remittance records showed only Ksh.1.72 billion had been transferred, a Ksh.515 million discrepancy that underscores the platform’s unreliable reporting system.

Illegal Fees and Procurement Breaches

Compounding the crisis, the report reveals that Kenyans were unlawfully charged Ksh.1.8 billion in “convenience fees” through eCitizen, violating government guidelines that require administrative charges to be proportional to transaction amounts. Shockingly, this overcharging continued even after regulatory warnings, with an additional Ksh.350 million illegally collected after a December 2023 gazette notice.

Procurement rules were also defied, with Ksh.492 million paid to unauthorized companies not listed in the official eCitizen contract. Worse still, the report also flagged four unauthorised transactions worth Sh127.85 million made on January 25, 2024, from MPesa paybill 222222, which was meant to transfer funds directly to the KCB Settlement Account. Instead, the money was sent to private entities, with no documentation or approvals provided for audit review.

Who Really Controls eCitizen?

Perhaps the most alarming revelation is the lack of full government control over a platform that hosts over 22,000 critical services, from driver’s licenses to business permits. Originally funded by the World Bank and the International Finance Corporation (IFC), the platform was handed over to the National Treasury in 2017. IFC formally transferred all relevant materials including contracts, source code, and business plans through a letter dated August 7, 2017. Despite this, eCitizen remains heavily dependent on a private consortium, Electronic Citizen Services (ECS) comprising Webmasters Kenya, Pesaflow, and Olive Tree Media.

Auditors question why a second handover agreement was signed in 2023 if the government already owned the system. This over-reliance on vendors creates a dangerous single point of failure, leaving the state vulnerable to exploitation and system breakdowns.

A Call for Urgent Reforms

With billions unaccounted for and services at risk, Gathungu’s report demands immediate action:

– Enforce Service Level Agreements SLAs to regulate payment providers.

– Conduct forensic audits to recover lost funds.

– The Government to take full control of eCitizen’s operations to eliminate vendor dependency.

As Kenya races toward digitization, the eCitizen scandal serves as a stark reminder that technology without accountability is a recipe for fraud and mismanagement of funds. The government must now act swiftly to restore public trust or risk collapsing the very system designed to modernize its services.

Source: Citizen Digital, Daily Nation, The Standard.

[/ays_block_subscribe]